Home

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Project Alpha: Nearly 30 Years After

  • Jul. 23rd, 2008 at 6:43 AM
Dancing Skeletons

In 1979, James S. McDonnell donated $500,000 to Washington University in Missouri for the establishment of the McDonnell Laboratory for Psychical Research. 

When James Randi heard about the project, he offered his services to the project to help avoid the problems Uri Gellar caused at the Stanford Research Institute. Randi's offer of help was disregarded; the researchers insisted they didn't need a magician to assist them in determining the validity of psychic claims.

Two years later, the institute's two chief researchers found what they believed to be two young men who demonstrated--under lab conditions--what the researchers called "psychic abilities." 

Around the same time, Randi held his own press conference with the psychics. He asked them, "Do you cheat?"

And the two men looked at each other and said, "Yes, we do."

The two men were amateur magicians sent by Randi to demonstrate how scientists can be duped by simple slight of hand. They were told, "If anyone asks you 'Are you cheating?' you must say 'Yes.'"

They were never asked.

Nearly thirty years later, both scientists and laymen are still being fooled by charlatains with claims of "psychic" or "divine" powers. Whenever I see books like The Secret or see Benny Hinn on TV, I think of Randi, thirty years ago, proving how easily we can all be fooled... because deep down, we all want to believe.

An intriguing interview with Randi on the subject.
The
wikipedia article.

Comments

[info]doogs19 wrote:
Jul. 23rd, 2008 02:21 pm (UTC)
About a decade or so ago, I popped on some late night TV and caught a few minutes of Benny Hinn. I am glad I did.

Benny was talking about how he had taken a day or so off from work. He was under the weather. As he was resting, he saw a tape of himself working his healing mojo. Below, I paraphrase what he said:

"So I see me asking the viewers to put their hands on the television to receive my healing. I thought to myself, 'No... this can't work for me.' But I did it anyways. And you know what?? IT WORKED!"

The man healed himself! High comedy.
[info]nestdweller wrote:
Jul. 23rd, 2008 02:52 pm (UTC)
Stage magicians can do some insanely cool stuff. I have a cousin who threw like, twenty chops with Smoke once upon a time, just to prove that his reaction time was so fast, he'd be able to cheat at LARP if he were so inclined. (Smoke claimed there was no way and lost, 20 - 0, or so. A shutout, at any rate. It may only have been 10 or 15 games of R-P-S.)
[info]notthebuddha wrote:
Jul. 24th, 2008 07:53 am (UTC)
Shhhhh!! You'll ruin it for me! :)

I was amazed at how many people make their sign before they even bring their hand out from behind their back, or will start with the same sign and copy which ever sign won last. Given that and the usual poor lighting at nighttime LARPS, it was a while before *I* even caught on to what I was doing.
[info]wunderworks wrote:
Jul. 28th, 2008 06:55 pm (UTC)
I have a hard time not throwing winning chops when I LARP. I go into this zone, the same zone I fence in, and start throwing chops that don't lose (unless it's a lot of people I throw against). My subconscious can pick up chops so fast it's scary.
[info]chris_goodwin wrote:
Jul. 23rd, 2008 03:14 pm (UTC)
[info]wyldelf wrote:
Jul. 23rd, 2008 06:39 pm (UTC)
What does "The Secret" have to do with physic or divine powers? I know a lot of it sounds like that, it's just about positive thought in a luring package.

I'm also speaking of the DVD. I heard the book was pretty awful in playing up making positive thinking sound like magic. Never read it, though.

The funny thing is, fooling yourself (or being fooled) into doing good things for yourself and others is just as beneficial to your personal happiness as making yourself do it. NLP is basically exactly that. It's a lot like laughing. No matter your mood or purpose in doing it, you'll feel better.

The only problem is when we're fooled to do things that aren't good for ourselves or harmful to others. Where people like Benny Hinn focus more time on lining their pockets by using trickery, and almost all the current advertising is based on using NLP to sell products.